5.1 Comparative analysis of physical, chemical, and biological induction methods

1. Overview of Induction Methods

Agarwood (resinous wood) formation in Aquilaria is a defense response triggered by injury, microbial infection, or chemical elicitors. Induction methods are classified into three main categories:

  1. Physical induction – mechanical wounding or injury.
  2. Chemical induction – application of chemicals/elicitors to stimulate resin biosynthesis.
  3. Biological induction – inoculation with fungi or bacteria that trigger defense pathways.

Each method has advantages, limitations, and applications.

2. Comparative Table

FeaturePhysical InductionChemical InductionBiological Induction
MechanismMechanical injury (drilling, chiseling) induces wound responseApplication of chemical elicitors (e.g., methyl jasmonate, NaCl, plant hormones) triggers defense metabolismMicrobial infection (fungi/bacteria) activates defense pathways and secondary metabolite synthesis
ExamplesDrilling holes, nailing, girdling, burningJasmonates, salicylic acid, hydrogen peroxide, plant extractsFusarium oxysporum, Lasiodiplodia theobromae, Aspergillus spp.
Resin QualityModerate; may be variable and unevenModerate to high, depends on elicitor type and concentrationHigh; often richest in sesquiterpenes and chromones
Resin YieldLow to moderateModerate; can be enhanced with repeated applicationsHigh; microbes often penetrate wood more effectively
Time to Resin FormationSlow (months to years)Moderate (weeks to months)Moderate to fast (weeks to months)
AdvantagesSimple, low-cost, no chemicals or microbesControlled induction; less labor-intensive than microbial inoculationProduces high-quality resin; mimics natural process
LimitationsLabor-intensive; stress may damage tree; low yieldRequires optimization; possible phytotoxicityRisk of uncontrolled infection; requires sterile inoculum; complex management
Application ScaleIndividual trees or small plotsPlantation or research scalePlantation, commercial, and experimental scale
Environmental ImpactMinimalChemical residues possibleLow if controlled; risk if pathogenic fungi spread

3. Mechanistic Notes

  1. Physical induction
    • Causes local tissue damage → triggers wound-induced defense pathways → deposition of resin in heartwood.
    • Often results in patchy resin formation.
  2. Chemical induction
    • Elicitors such as methyl jasmonate or salicylic acid activate secondary metabolite pathways, especially sesquiterpene and chromone biosynthesis.
    • Allows precise control of timing and concentration.
  3. Biological induction
    • Certain fungi (e.g., Fusarium oxysporumLasiodiplodia theobromae) infect wounded tissue → tree responds with defense metabolite accumulation.
    • Microbial enzymes may aid resin diffusion into wood.
    • Considered most effective for high-quality agarwood in commercial plantations.

4. Integrated Strategies

  • Combination approaches often yield the best results:
    • Physical wounding + microbial inoculation → fast and high-quality resin.
    • Chemical elicitor sprays after minor wounding → uniform induction.
  • Precision induction:
    • Holes drilled in a systematic pattern → fungal inoculation → resin deposition along defined zones.
    • Allows controlled harvest without killing the tree.

5. Recommendations for Plantation Use

MethodBest forNotes
PhysicalSmall-scale, experimentalLow cost, easy to apply, but lower yield
ChemicalMedium-scale plantationsRequires trained personnel; repeated application may be needed
BiologicalLarge-scale commercial plantationsHigh-quality agarwood; must use certified, non-pathogenic inoculum